Anyone who says one is a POS is just bashing b/c they are being brand loyal to the Dodge. I have owned a Gen 2 Lightning for 9 years (a '99 until '04 and now I have an '04 that I bought new and still own).
I haven't driven a stickshift RC SRT-10, so I cannot compare the handling of the two trucks.
As some have stated the L is easy to mod, and is very reliable even after substantial mods. My truck runs low-12s on drag radials, but its not close to stock either (Kenne Bell supercharger upgrade, long tube headers, upgraded MAF, injectors, fuel pumps... the last two mods probably didn't need to be done, but I'm conservative and cautious).
You may not like the looks of them... that's just a subjective opinion, if we're all being honest.
As far as fit and finish, I don't have any issues. No squeaking dash or rattles to speak of. Everything still opens and closes with the stock-like "thunk" you should get when doing so.
Stock for stock, the RC SRT-10 is faster. No one would doubt that. But that doesn't make the Lightning a POS. Given the fact I've logged over 80k miles in a Gen 2 Lightning... I think I can speak from at least a little bit of experience.
I am sure my new '05 QC will serve me just as well (actually better... now that I really need that 2nd row of seats!):rock: